Sports Stars Are Paid Too Much Essay Scholarships

College basketball is going to be dominating winter sports until the NCAA’s March Madness championships finally end in April. Meanwhile, between games there’s another contest taking place: debates about whether colleges should pay athletes in two big-time sports—football and men’s basketball. This replaces 1980s television beer commercials pitting “tastes great” versus “less filling” factions among sports fans.

So, to start the “play for pay” games, let’s assume that salaries replace scholarships in big-time men’s college sports. What happens, for example, to the college player if he were paid $100,000 per year?

A full athletic scholarship (a “grant-in-aid”) at an NCAA Division I university is about $65,000 if you enroll at a college with high tuition. This includes such private colleges as Stanford, Duke, Northwestern, University of Southern California, Syracuse, and Vanderbilt. The scholarship is $45,000 for tuition and $20,000 for room, board and books. At state universities, the scholarship would be lower if you were an “in state” student—because tuition would be about $13,000. But if Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh recruits nationwide and wants a high school player from California or Texas, the University of Michigan out-of-state tuition bumps up to about the same as that charged by the private colleges.

That’s the old model. In the new era, a coach could offer a recruit a salary instead of a scholarship. Does a $100,000 salary give the student-athlete a better deal than the $65,000 scholarship?

The $100,000 salary is impressive. A future Heisman Trophy winner might command more, but $100,000 is not bad for an 18-year-old high school recruit. But since it’s a salary, not a scholarship, it is subject to federal and state income taxes. Tuition and college expenses would not be deductible because the income level surpasses the IRS eligibility limit.

So, a student-athlete paid a salary would owe $23,800 in federal income tax and $6,700 in state taxes, a total of $30,500. In cities that levy an employee payroll tax, the salaried student’s taxes go up about $2,400 per year. Income taxes then are $32,900. And, as an employee, the player would have to pay at least $2,000 in other taxes, such as Social Security, for a total of $34,900. This leaves the college player with $65,100. Since college bills come to $65,000, the player has $100 left.

By comparison, how bad was the scholarship model? According to the federal tax code, the $45,000 tuition award is deductible, but room and board are not. The student-athlete will be able to deduct book expenses and qualify for a tax credit under the American Opportunity Tax Credit (AOTC), reducing his tax. The bottom line is that the student-athlete gets a $200 refund in federal taxes and pays $820 in state taxes, for a total tax bill of $620. There’s no local payroll tax because he was not an employee. This means $64,380 of the $65,000 scholarship can go toward paying academic expenses of $65,000.

How does the salary compare to the scholarship for student purchasing power? The $100,000 salary gives the college sports “employee” an advantage of $720 per year, the difference between his net salary of $65,100 versus the scholarship player’s net of $64,380. That’s not great news for the salaried player. It’s bad news for the athletics department which paid $100,000 in salary rather than $65,000 in scholarship, driving up expenses $35,000.

What’s clear is that paying salaries for college players is a taxing situation. Each case will vary by state. The case above used a moderate tax state, Kentucky. Massachusetts (a.k.a. “Taxachusetts”) will be more painful. In following all the “pay for play” contests, the skilled players will be dueling accountants and agents.

There’s crucial a human dimension to the “numbers game.” Star high school athletes are talented. Coaches and sports journalists reinforce this perception. But players and their families often overestimate a player’s market worth. They fail to recognize how many equally talented players are competing for a salary. Many All-State players may be surprised that college coaches are not willing to pay them $100,000 or even $50,000.


High school and college players understandably use the National Football League and the National Basketball Association salaries as the gold standard. Multimillion-dollar contracts make professional sports part of the American Dream. But since the NFL and NBA are the pinnacle, it’s good to add the full range of professional sports leagues when a college player plans his financial future. Former college stars on professional indoor football squads make about $225 per game—with a $25 bonus if the team wins. Outside the NBA, players in the professional developmental league—one step from making a NBA squad—make about $43,000 per year. The college scholarship model may not be so bad for student-athletes after all.

Download Your Printable March Madness Bracket Here

John Thelin, a professor at the University of Kentucky, is author of A History of American Higher Education, published by Johns Hopkins University Press. In 2006 he was selected for the “Ivy League at 50” roster of outstanding scholar-athlete alumni. He most recently wrote for MONEY on Why Students Are the Biggest Losers in Today’s College Bowl Games.



Why Pro Athletes Get Paid Too Much

"Baseball is the belly of society. Straighten out baseball and you'll straighten out the rest of the world." Bill Lee People have a tendency to pay for things they love to see, but has it gone too far? Bill Lee thinks it has and so do many other baseball fans. There was once a time where a father could go to the ballpark with his family for $10 and see their favorite Yankee play, but now things have changed. For a family of four to go see a Major League Baseball game it will cost them anywhere from $200 to $250 to sit in tight, compact seats, while trying to watch the same man as everyone else is. People ask why professional athletes get paid too much; it's because we allow it. What we pay for, why we pay, and where our money goes are only a few of the ways we know that professional athletes are paid too much.

Big names in the sport business get paid a lot of money to play around and entertain the crowds. Meanwhile, the crowd pays a lot of money be entertained. The crowd is full of doctors, lawyers, teachers, and mechanics that have paid thousands of dollars to earn the money to get to the game in the first place. The players that are being watched normally haven't worked hard towards a good education. Some have been recruited right out of high school, while most got huge scholarships to play sports at prestigious schools. These schools will do almost anything to keep their best players in school. So they athletes can eventually make it to the professional level, with or without a degree. One might argue that some people get money for being good with their brains, why shouldn't people get money for being good with their bodies; on the other hand, since when have we paid someone $12 million to think and have fun? It's not all the athletes' fault though. Once the player becomes good, many different teams will seek him or her after. Soon after, the highest bidder will get he or she on his team. What is the difference between $80 million and $90 million? Players will even stop playing completely if they think that they aren't making enough money. So much for the idea of playing for fun. The world of sports has become another business world, which is the reason why athletes get paid so much.

Alex Rodriguez, Michael Jordan, and Roger Clemens will make a combined $12,500 an hour over the course of the next 5 years. That's $547,500,000, enough to support 100 families for at least 50 years. (Peden, 2000, Sept. 29) Yes, I know that they are good at what they do, but so are the trash men that...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Should College Athletes Get Paid to Play

786 words - 3 pages Should College Athletes Get Paid to Play Forget about the game-winning touchdown, forget about the cheerleader girlfriend, and forget the pageantry. What about the hard earned money college athletes will never see and earned? In the world of college sports its win or go home, and to the winners go the spoils. Most successful college sports teams rake in millions of dollars in revenue. Steve Spurrier, the coach for the Florida...

Examine why superstars get paid so much and the effects on the industry involved.

1638 words - 7 pages The film industry today is priceless in terms of movie production costs and salaries. The production of 'Superman's Return' has just finished beating the world record for the most expensive movie ever to be made, with a production cost of $250 million. But why do film companies like Columbia Pictures invest so much money in one movie and pay enormous salaries to film stars? What effect does this have on the film industry? Is it just because...

College Athletes Should Not Get Paid for Play

929 words - 4 pages The argument whether a student-athlete should be paid to play or not be paid is one that spans the ages. College sports are considered to be of amateur status by the NCAA. Therefore they believe student-athletes should not receive a pay check to participate in a sport. However on the other end of the spectrum, many critics believe that student-athletes should receive pay for play because not only are they participating in a sport, they are...

Should Pro Players be paid so much??

651 words - 3 pages Should NHL players be able to participate in the Olympics? There are many upsides to this, but just as many downsides also. By the player taking place in the events would they get hurt or cause damage to property?Last Olympic season marks the first time that all NHL players were aloud to partake in the games. The NHL had hoped hockey would be one...

What Physicians do, how much they get paid, all about physicians.

595 words - 2 pages PhysiciansPhysicians serve a fundamental role in our society and have an effect upon all our lives. Physicians are licensed practitioners of medicine who examine patients, obtain medical histories, and order, perform, and interpret diagnostic tests. They diagnose illnesses, prescribe medications, and administer treatment for people suffering from injury or diseases. Physicians examine patients, obtain medical histories, and...

Why College Athletes Should NOT be Paid

1997 words - 8 pages The proposal of payment toNCAA student-athletes has begun major conversations and arguments nationwide with people expressing their take on it. “This tension has been going on for years. It has gotten greater now because the magnitude of dollars has gotten really large” (NCAA). I am a student athlete at Nicholls State University and at first thought, I thought it would be a good idea to be able to be paid as a student-athlete.After much...

College Athletes: Why They Should be Paid

1615 words - 6 pages College athletics have been incredibly profitable businesses for many years. With the advent of televised sporting events, the profit margin has increased exponentially. The Texas Longhorns’ football program alone grosses 104 million dollars annually ( So, where is all that money going? Most of it goes right back to the school. The athletes who practice for endless hours and devote their lives to the sports get nothing but the...

Why Should College Athletes be Paid?

1137 words - 5 pages Should College Athletes Get Paid? Many collegiate athletes put as much if not more time into their sport as they do in their school work. There is has been an ongoing argument about this for a while and there are many for and against it. The People that are for paying the athletes say that the athletes...

College Sports and Money

1615 words - 6 pages College athletes should not be paid and the reasoning for that opinion is that college athletes attend school to get a degree not to become rich and famous afterwards. A majority of college athletes are attending school with all expenses paid so there is no reason for them to be receiving money from outside sources. If college athletes were to be paid for playing their specific sport then a lot of them would not try as hard as they do now...

Should College Athletes be Paid?

997 words - 4 pages Should College Athletes be Paid? ! There are many fans of college sports in the United States. Many are die hard fans of their team and would do anything to help their team out. One huge debate between fans of college sports is whether or not college athletes should be paid to play their sports. There are many different opinions out there, and very strong points for all of them. Ask any fan of college...

Paying College Athletes

2002 words - 8 pages Paying College Athletes It is six o'clock in the afternoon at Florida State University. A young college football player has just finished a three-hour practice and is walking down the sidewalk with his teammates. They enter the local McDonald's for a burger. The young football star reaches into his pocket and pulls out a hand full of lint. He cannot work a part-time job like the vast majority of his peers, cause he already has a full time job...

One thought on “Sports Stars Are Paid Too Much Essay Scholarships

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *